Allergen Data Collection - Update: Cow's Milk (Bos domesticus)
Internet Symposium on Food Allergens 4(1): 19-106 (2002) [http://www.food-allergens.de]
1 Prevalence of Cow's Milk Allergy

1.1 General Population

Prevalences within the author's selected populations are listed. Those that are assigned randomly selected ("unselected") with numbers more than 500 may be regarded as representative of the "general population". Inclusion criteria may involve circumstances not related to atopic predisposition according to current knowledge.
 
Country / Subjects Sensitivity / Allergy to References
Australia, Melbourne
620 unselected children (age of <2 years)
cow's milk 2.0% Hill et al. 1997, 1999
Brazil, Campinas
114 newborns at term
cow's milk 1.8% (prospective follow-up) Lopez et al. 1999
Canada
3000 unselected children (private practice)
cow's milk 0.3% (case history) Collins-Williams 1956
Canada
787 unselected children (<3 years of age)
cow's milk 7.5% (2 open challenges) Gerrard et al. 1973
Denmark, Odense
a) 1749 unselected newborns
b) 52% exclusively brest-fed infants
a) cow's milk 2.2%
b) cow's milk 1.0% (elimination/challenge)
Host et al. 1988
Host & Halken 1990
Estonia
251 consecutive born infants
cow's milk 1.2%, 0.8% (SPT) at 6 and 12 months Julge et al. 1997
Estonia, Tartu
237 consecutive born infants (1993-94)
cow's milk 12, 21%, 26%, and 23%
at 0.5, 1, 2, and 5 years of age (beta-LG specific RAST >/= class 1) 
cow's milk 1.7%, 0.9%, and 0%
at 0.5, 1, and 2 years of age (SPT)
Julge et al. 2001
Finland
unselected children (<6 months of age)
cow's milk 1.3-1.9% (with intestinal form only: 0.06%) Kuitunen et al. 1985
Finland, Helsinki
866 children from well-baby clinic (1-6 years of age)
cow's milk 2-5% (open challenge) Kajosaari 1982
Finland, Helsinki
6209 infants followed prospectively from birth
cow's milk 1.9% (challenge at a mean age of 6.7 months) Saarinen & Savilahti 2000
France
a) 33110 persons who answered a questionnaire addressed to a representative sample of the French population (age of <61 years)
b) 1121 persons with food allergies selected from group a) received a second questionnaire (study period 1997-98)
a) food allergy 3.2%
b) cow's milk 8% (0.26% in group a)
(2 phase survey, questionnaires)
Kanny et al. 2001
Germany
1235 unselected preschool children (5-6 years)
cow's milk 3.9% (SPT) Schäfer et al. 1999
Germany, Augsburg
1537 subjects between 25 and 74 years of age
(study period from 1997 to 1998)
cow's milk  3.8% (SPT)
cow's milk 2.3% (corresponding frequency estimates for the representative study base, n=4178) 
Schäfer et al. 2001
Iceland, Reykjavik
502 unselected adults
cow's milk 1.2% (RAST) Gislason et al. 1999
Japan
1336 children in nusery school < 6 years of age (12.6% reported symptoms of  immediate-type food allergy)
cow's milk 4.0% (questionnaire) Iikura et al. 1999
Netherlands, Maastricht
1158 unselected newborns (followed prospectively from birth to 1 year of age)
cow's milk 2.8% (elimination / challenge tests) Schrander et al. 1993b
Norway, Oslo
2721 unselected children (population-based cohort)
a) point prevalence at age of 2.5 years
b) cumulative prevalence at age of 2 years
c) prevalence of CMA in children without parents perceived reactions to milk, but perceived reaction to other food (egg) and
d) prevalence of CMA in children with no perceived reaction to any food, but reported chronic conditions which could be due to food
a) cow's milk 1.1%*
b) cow's milk 3.2%
c) cow's milk 0.2%
d) cow's milk 1.8%
(parentally perceived reactions followed by stepwise diagnostic procedure including diet trials at home, SPT, and open challenge and DBPCFC)
Eggesbø et al. 2001

* according to authors underestimate, as unrecognized reactions were detected

Spain, Valencia
1663 unselected newborns (follow-up to 1 year of age)
cow's milk 0.36% (clinical history, SPT, RAST) Sanz Ortega et al. 2001
Sweden
1397 unselected adults (20-44 years of age)
cow's milk 1.0% (RAST, questionaire) Björnsson et al. 1996
Sweden, Linköping
healthy girls at birth and mean age of 3, 8, 25, and 48 months (n=57-86, all Rh negative)
cow's milk 0%, 4.6%, 9.0%, 0%, 1.2% (RAST) Hattevig et al. 1984
Sweden, Malmö
1079 unselected children (age at onset 2-44 weeks)
cow's milk in 1.9% (elimination / challenge tests) Jakobsson & Lindberg 1979
Sweden, Uppsala
414 unselected adults
cow's milk 0.7% (RAST) Gislason et al. 1999
Turkey, Adana
1348 unselected children (age 15 weeks)
cow's milk in 1.6% (elimination / challenge tests) Altintas et al. 1995
UK
16420 randomly selected adults (age of >15 years)
cow's milk 0.71% (interview survey, questionnaire) Emmett et al. 1999
UK, Isle of Wight
609 unselected newborns
cow's milk 2.5% (case history) Hide & Guyer 1983
UK, Isle of Wight
unselected children
(birth cohort of 1456 consecutively born children)
a) cow's milk 4.1% (SPT)
b) cow's milk appr. 1.5% (SPT at age of 4 years, n=981)
a) Dean 1997
b) Arshad et al. 2001
USA
appr. 1000 unselected infants (private practice)
cow's milk appr. 7% (case history) Clein 1951
USA
403 unselected infants (well-baby clinic)
cow's milk 1% (history, skin test) Bachman & Dees 1957
USA
299 unselected newborns
cow's milk 1% (history, skin test) Mueller et al. 1963
USA, Ann Arbor, MI
66598 children from randomly selected public elementary schools
cow's milk 1.4% (questionnaire, school completed) Rhim & Morris 2001
USA, Denver, CO
480 unselected children (age of 0 to 3 years)
cow's milk 2.2% (challenge tests) Bock 1987

1.2 Subjects with Atopic or Other Diseases
 
Country / Subjects Sensitivity / Allergy to References
Finland, Oulu
57, 43, and 42 children with atopic dermatits
cow's milk 12%, 9.3%, and 7.1% in patients < 1 year, 1-3 years, and 3-15 years of age (SPT) Hannuksela 1987
Finland, Tampere
113 infants with atopic eczema (age of 2-24 months)
cow's milk 48% (oral challenge) Kekki et al. 1997
France
81 cases of anaphylactic shock to food (from 1991-1992)
cow's milk 6.5% Moneret-Vautrin & Kanny 1995
France
80 cases of food- related anaphylaxis (from 1993-97)
cow's milk 6.3% (reported to CICBAA databank) European Commission 1998
France
45 children with severe food allergies enrolled in a personalized care project in schools
11% cow's milk (SBPCFC or DBPCFC) Moneret-Vautrin et al. 2001
France, Pierre Benite
a) 580 patients with adverse reactions to food
b) 60 cases of anaphylaxis (study period 1984-92)
a) cow's milk 18%
b) cow's milk 3.3%
Andre et al. 1994
France, Nancy and Toulouse
544 food allergic children
cow's milk 13%, goat's milk 0.55% (food challenge) Rance et al. 1999b
France, Toulouse
142 food allergic children
cow's milk 9.2 % (labial food challenge) Rance & Dutau 1997
France, Toulouse
378 food allergic children
cow's milk 12% (food challenge) Rance et al. 1999a
Germany,Berlin
107 children with atopic dermatitis (and suspicion of food allergy)
cow's milk 51% (n=92, DBPCFC) Niggemann et al. 1999b
Germany,Bonn
150  food allergic children (egg white, milk, cod fish, wheat, peanut and/or soybean)
cow's milk 52.0% (RAST) Liappis & Starke 1999
Italy, Bari
134 patients with atopic dermatitis
cow's milk 13% (case history), 21% (RAST) Bonifazi et al. 1978
Italy, Florence
54 episodes of food-dependent anaphylaxis in 44 children (age of 1 month to 16 years) (from 1994-1996)
cow's milk 22%
goat's milk 4%
Novembre et al. 1998
Italy, Milan
202 with chronic urticaria and suspected food allergy
cow's milk 1.0% (DBPCFC) Pigatto & Valsecchi 2000
Italy, Palermo
204 children (median age of 6.3 months) with gastroesophageal reflux
cow's milk 9.3% (history)
cow's milk 46% (RAST, SPT, eosinophils)
cow's milk 42% (challenge test)
Iacono et al. 1996
Italy, Rome
371 children with food allergy
cow's milk 54% (RAST) Giampietro et al. 1992
Japan, Gifu / Nabu
children with asthma and/or atopic dermatitis from a) Gifu (n = 167) and b) Nanbu (n = 146)
cow's milk a) 8.1% (Nanbu), b) 19% (Gifu)
(RAST)
Agata et al. 1994
Japan, Kochi
200 patients with atopic dermatitis and suspected food allergy
cow's milk 52% (food challenge) Ogura et al. 2001
Japan, Tokyo
39 children with positive food challenge
cow's milk 28% (food challenge) Iwasaki et al. 1994
Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur
148 adults with symptoms of nasal congestion and rhinorrhea
cow's milk 12% (SPT) Gendeh et al. 2000
Netherlands
131 cases of food- induced anaphylaxis
(from 1993-1997)
cow's milk 8.4% (survey, reported to the TNO Nutrition and Food Research Institute) European Commission 1998
Netherlands, Rotterdam
91 patients with atopic dermatitis
cow's milk 47% (SAFT) Oranje et al. 1992
Poland
163 food allergic infants
cow's milk 64% (RAST) Hofman 1994
Poland, Warshaw
153 hospitalized infants with respiratory symptoms
cow' milk 21% Maciejewski et al. 1995
Singapore
124 children with food-induced anaphylaxis
cow's milk and/or egg 11% Goh et al. 1999
South Africa, Cape Town
112 children with atopic dermatitis (age of 5 months to 13 years)
cow's milk 20% (reported by parents) Steinman & Potter 1994
Spain, Madrid
355 food allergic children
cow's milk 25% (SPT, RAST) Crespo et al. 1995
Spain, Pamplona
74 patients with atopic dermatitis
cow's milk 37% (SPT, RAST, Histamine Release) Resano et al. 1998
Sweden
a) 61 cases and b) 55 cases
of food- induced anaphylaxis (from 1994-1996)
a) cow's milk 20% (reported to the National Food Administration)
b) cow's milk 5.5% (Hospital Reports)
European Commission 1998
Switzerland, Geneva
74 children with atopic dermatitis (age of 6 months to 16 years, median 2.5 years)
cow's milk 19% (SPT)
cow's milk 15% (history, RAST, and challenge) 
Eigenmann & Calza 2000
Switzerland, Zurich
402 food allergic adults (study period 1978-87)
cow's milk 16%
(cheese only 6.2%, milk only 3.5%)
Wüthrich 1993
Switzerland, Zurich
383 food allergic patients (study period 1990-94)
cow's milk 11%
cheese 5.7%
Etesamifar & Wüthrich 1998
Thailand
100 asthmatic children
milk 2% (SPT) Kongpanichkul et al. 1997
Turkey, Erdine
50 asthmatic children (age of 1.5 to 6 years) with specific serum IgE to foods (egg white, milk, codfish, wheat, peanut and/or soybean)
cow's milk 18% (SPT) Yazicioglu et al. 1999
UK, London
100 patients with food intolerance
cow's milk 46%, cheese only 5% (repeated challenge) Lessof et al. 1980
UK, Manchester
172 patients expierenced anaphylactic reactions to foods (from 1994-1996)
cow's milk 1.7% (suspected cause of patients' worst reaction) Pumphrey & Stanworth 1996
USA, Baltimore, MD
196 food-allergic patients with atopic dermatitis
cow's milk 50% (n=109, DBPCFC) Sampson & Ho 1997
USA, Baltimore, MD
11 beef-allergic patients (DBPCFC)
cow's milk 73% (DBPCFC) Werfel et al. 1997a
USA, Baltimore, MD
63 patients with atopic dermatitis (age of 6 months to 20 years)
cow's milk 11% (history, RAST, and challenge)  Eigenmann et al. 1998
USA, Boston, MA
279 adults with exercise- induced anaphylaxis (study period 1980-98)
cow's milk 4% (reported trigger) Shadick et al. 1999
USA, Denver, CO
a) 74 age of <3 years
b) 111 age of 3-19 years
a) cow's milk 57% (DBPCFC)
b) cow's milk 14% (DBPCFC)
Bock & Atkins 1990
USA, Durham, NC
a) 113 food allergic children with atopic dermatitis
b) 63 DBPCFC positive children of a)
a) cow's milk 23% (SPT)
b) cow's milk 17% (DBPCFC)
Sampson & McCaskill 1985
USA, Little Rock, AR
165 patients with atopic dermatitis
cow's milk 19% (SPT) from which 50% were DBPCFC-positive  Burks et al. 1998
USA, New Haven, CT
98 infants and children with multiple gastrointestinal allergies 
soy and milk 62%
milk and gluten 3%
Gryboski & Kocoshis 1980
USA, New Haven, CT
38 children with ulcerative colitis (age of <10 years)
cow's milk 13% (history) Gryboski 1993
USA, OH
148 respiratory-allergic children with reproduced symptoms after food challenge
cow's milk 29% Ogle et al. 1980

1.3 Prevalence of Associated Allergies
 
Country / Subjects Sensitivity / Allergy to References
Australia, Parkville
42 children with CMA (followed for 2 years)
egg 67%, peanut 55% (challenge test) Hill et al. 1994
Finland, Helsinki
19 children with CMA
soybean 32% Paganus et al. 1992
France, Gif Sur Yvette / Paris
58 patients with CMA and specific IgE to bovine CAS
sheep's milk: ovine CAS 98% (RAST)
goat's milk: caprine CAS 93% (RAST)
rat's milk CAS 59% (RAST)
rabbit's milk CAS 57% (RAST)
Bernard et al. 1999
Germany, Augsburg
59 subjects sensitized to cow's milk in SPT (25-74 years of age) (study period from 1997 to 1998)
Foods SPT  Aeroallergens SPT 
egg  57% grass pollen 75%
peanut  17% birch pollen 76%
pork  40% rye pollen 80%
mackerel  56% mugwort 73%
celery  15% Alternaria 63%
hazelnut  14% Cladosporium 63%
wheat  29% cat 81%
soybean  36% dog 71%
crab  27% house duste mite 73%
Schäfer et al. 2001
Italy, Rome
26 children with CMA (DBPCFC)
goat's milk 92% (DBPCFC) Bellioni-Businco et al. 1999
Italy, Rome
25 children with CMA (DBPCFC)
mare's milk 8% (SPT)
mare's milk 4% (DBPCFC)
Businco et al. 2000
Sweden, Malmö
20 infants with CMA (age of <12 months)
soybean in 35% Jakobsson & Lindberg 1979
Thailand, Bangkok
cow's milk-sensitive children
soybean 17% Harikul et al. 1995
USA, New Haven, CT
98 infants and children with multiple gastrointestinal allergies 
soy and milk 62%
milk and gluten 3%
Gryboski & Kocoshis 1980
USA, San Diego, CA
cow's milk-sensitive infants
soybean 25% Wilson & Hamburger 1988
USA, San Diego, CA
93 children with CMA (<3.5 years)
soybean 14 % (DBPCFC, open challenge, or convincing history of an anaphylactic reaction) Zeiger et al. 1999

2 Outgrowing of Cow's Milk Allergy
 
Country / Subjects Sensitivity References
Australia, Victoria
47 with CMA (age of  3-66 months) with onset of symptoms
a) <1 hour (n=15),
b) 1 to 20 hours (n=24) or,
c) >20 hours (n=8)
Oral tolerance acquired at follow-up of 16 months in: a) 40%, b) 42%, c) 25% of patients Hill et al. 1989
Australia, Victoria
97 children with CMA
Tolerance in 28% by 2 years, in 56% by 4 years, and 78% by 6 years of age (DBPCFC) Bishop et al. 1990
Canada
150 children with CMA
Tolerance in 6% by 1 year, 20% by 2 years, in 30% by 3 years, and 53% by 12 years of age Gerrard et al. 1967
Denmark, Odense
39 children with CMA
Total recovery in 56% by 1 year, 77% by 2 years, and 87% by 3 years of age; cow's milk allergy persisted in 24% of patients with early IgE sensitization to cow's milk Host & Halken 1990
Finland, Oulu
56 children with CMA in infancy (re-examinations at the age of 10 years)
Positivity to cow's milk proteins:
66% by SPT
13% by RAST
7.1% by clinical reactivity
Tikkanen et al. 2000
Finland, Tampere
37 patients with a history of CMA (mean age of 28 months)
Oral tolerance acquired at follow-up of 13 months
in 65% of patients
Isolauri et al. 1992
France, Nancy and Toulouse
68 children with CMA
Sensitivity to cow's milk according to age groups:
0-1 year in 22%
1-3 years in 56%
3-6 years in 19%
6-15 years in 2.9%
(SPT and/or RAST, food challenge)
Rance et al. 1999b
Germany, Berlin and Freiburg
216 children of a prospective birth cohort (sensitization rates were estimated for the reference population of 4082 children by weighted analysis)
Point prevalence of sensitization:
1-3 years in appr. 5-6%
5 years in appr. 6-7%
6 years in appr. 5-6%

Annual incidence of sensitization:
1 years in appr. 5-6%
2 years in appr. 4%
3 years in appr. 3-4%
5 years in appr. 1-2%
6 years in appr. 1-2%
(Sensitivity to cow's milk during follow-up by RAST)

Kulig et al. 1999
Italy, Palermo
86 consecutive children with IgE-mediated or non-IgE-mediated CMA (median age at diagnosis 4 months)
Oral tolerance acquired in 30%, 55%, and 70% of children after 1, 2, and 3 years of cow's milk free diet, respectively (DBPCFC) Carroccio et al. 2000b
Italy, Rome
37 children with CMA
Tolerance acquired in 68% at age of 2 years; 33% did not tolerate cow's milk at age of 6 years Businco et al. 1985
Israel, Tel-Aviv
347 subjects sensitized to food (n=347)
Sensitivity to cow's milk RAST
0-2 years 5.5%
3-5 years 4.3%
6-10 years 4.9%
21-30 years 2.3%
>30 years 5.2%
total 16.4%
Kornizky et al. 1999
Japan, Gifu
22 children with CMA and atopic dermatitis
41% Improvement rate in children aged from <1 year to >6 years Iida et al. 1995
Netherlands, Groningen
23 children with CMA
Oral tolerance acquired in 13%, 48%, 74% and 78% of children at the age of 1, 2, 3 and 4 years, respectively Olsder et al. 1995
Netherlands, Maastricht
37 children with CMA
Oral tolerance acquired in 15%, 22%, 51% and 67% of the children at the age of 1, 2, 3 and 4 years, respectively;
90% with initial IgE levels <10 kU/L and 47% with initial IgE >/= 10 kU/L became tolerant
Schrander et al. 1992
Switzerland, Zurich
34 adults with CMA
Oral tolerance acquired in 28% after 4 years of disease Stoger & Wüthrich 1993
Turkey, Adana
21 children with CMA (age 15 weeks)
29% recovered within 2 years Altintas et al. 1995
USA
Food allergic patients 
soy, egg, milk, wheat, and peanut:
26% loss (after 1 year of onset, DBPCFC)
Sampson & Scanlon 1989
USA, Baltimore, MD
29 children with CMA
Tolerance acquired in 38% at median age of 3 years (DBPCFC) James & Sampson 1992

3 Symptoms of Cow's Milk Allergy
 
Symptoms & Case Reports
systemic reactions
anaphylaxis (20, 21, 24, 36, 40, 46, 44, 54, 55, 56, 64, 70, 71, 76, 78, 82, 92, 93***, 96, 100), excercise induced anaphylaxis (55, 59, 62, 75), fatal reactions (47, 49**, 89)

cutaneous symptoms
angioedema (8, 18, 17, 44, 55, 78, 81, 100), angioneurotic edema (91), atopic dermatitis (22, 23, 24, 27, 35, 78, 87, 88, 92), contact urticaria (19), dermatitis (68), eczema (3, 6, 8, 9, 17, 25, 29, 30, 51, 69), eczematous lesions (91), erythema (29, 55, 88, 96), exanthema (6), red itchy eyes (100), hives (100), lips edema (10, 100), pruritus (2), redness (55), swelling of eyelids (55), urticaria (2, 6, 8, 10, 17, 18, 22, 23, 26, 30, 39, 44, 51, 55, 69, 78, 81, 87, 88, 91, 92), generalized urticaria (100), localized urticaria (100***), acute-onset urticaria (86, 100***), chronic urticaria (63)

gastrointestinal symptoms
abdominal cramps (2), abdominal distention (42), abdominal pain (44, 91, 92, 96), colic (3, 51, 68, 91, 92), infantil colic syndrome (1, 5, 6), colitis (57, 65), constipation (3, 68), chronic constipation (49, 52, 90), diarrhea (2, 3, 6, 10, 11, 15, 17, 25, 29, 39, 42, 44, 51, 68, 69, 92), chronic diarrhea (12, 74), gastric dysrhythmia (98), delayed gastric emptying (98), food protein-induced enterocolitis syndrome (absence of specific IgE) (72, 95), protein-sensitive enteropathy (94), eosinophilic colitis (31, 85), eosinophilic gastroenteritis (28, 99), gastroenteritis (11), gastro- oesophageal reflux (13, 58, 60, 67), morphologic lesion (15), nausea (44), proctitis (32), allergic proctocolitis (84), eosinophilic proctocolitis (97), progressive small bowel mucosal damage (26), occult intestinal bleeding (4), oropharyngeal itching / swelling (39, 44), oropharyngeal pruritus (73), edema of tongue (10, 100), acute pancreatitis (33), loose stools (69, 91), vomiting (2, 3, 6, 11, 17, 22, 25, 68, 69, 81, 83, 91, 92), protracted vomiting (92), in general (30, 78, 87)

respiratory symptoms
allergic alveolitis (7, 16), asthma (3, 10, 11, 18, 22, 39, 44, 45, 48, 50, 55, 70, 76, 83), bronchospasm (29), bronchial obstruction (91), bronchitis (6, 17), choking (100), conjunctivitis (76), conjunctival injection (100), cough (25, 51, 96), dyspnea (51, 55, 73), nasal blockade (73), allergic rhinitis (22), rhinitis (29, 44, 55, 81, 91), rhinoconjunctivitis (44, 45, 55), rhinorrhea (100), serious rhinorrhea (73), sneezing (73, 100), upper respiratory symptoms (100***), wheeze (25, 51, 68, 80, 87, 81, 100)

other symptoms
association with cytomegalovirus colitis* (66), infantile autism* (53), aversion  (91), anal fistula and fissures (49), growth retardation / failure to thrive (3, 6), insomnia (14), iron deficiency anemia in 20-70% (11), irritability (91), lactic acidosis (79), Melkersson-Rosenthal syndrome* (61), migraine* (38), necrotizing enterocolitis (43), steroid- resistant nephrotic syndrome (41), recurrent otitis media (77), pallor (17), psychological disturbance (3), pulmonary hemosiderosis (34), sleep disturbances (91), tension-fatigue syndrome (37), lethargy (71)

* controversial / hypothetical, ** possibly due to partially hydrolyzed whey formula, *** mediated by skin contact

(1) Harris et al. 1977
(2) Bonifazi et al. 1978
(3) Buisseret 1978
(4) Ivady et al. 1978
(5) Jakobsson & Lindberg 1978
(6) Jakobsson & Lindberg 1979
(7) Chetty 1982
(8) Firer et al. 1982
(9) Taylor et al. 1982
(10) Businco et al. 1983a
(11) Podleski et al. 1984
(12) Businco et al. 1985
(13) Forget & Arends 1985
(14) Kahn et al. 1985, 1987
(15) Kuitunen et al. 1985
(16) Vergesslich et al. 1985
(17) Hill et al. 1986
(18) Koers 1986
(19) Salo et al. 1986
(20) Wüthrich & Hofer 1986
(21) Jarmoc & Primack 1987
(22) Host & Samuelsson 1988
(23) Prahl et al. 1988
(24) Businco et al. 1989
(25) Hill et al. 1989
(26) Iyngkaran et al. 1989
(27) Cantani et al. 1990
(28) Hill & Milla 1990
(29) Husby et al. 1990
(30) Isolauri et al. 1990
(31) Wilson et al. 1990
(32) Lake 1991
(33) de Diego et al. 1992
(34) Fossati et al. 1992
(35) James & Sampson 1992
(36) Jones et al. 1992
(37) Kondo et al. 1992
(38) Mylek 1992
(39) Norgaard & Bindslev-Jensen 1992
(40) Sampson et al. 1992
(41) Sieniawska et al. 1992
(42) Hayashi et al. 1993
(43) Michaud et al. 1993
(44) Stoger & Wüthrich 1993
(45) Bernaola et al. 1994
(46) Businco et al. 1994
(47) Malmheden Yman et al. 1994
(48) Rossi et al. 1994
(49) Tarim et al. 1994
(50) Vargiu et al. 1994
(51) Altintas et al. 1995
(52) Iacono et al. 1995a
(53) Lucarelli et al. 1995
(54) Moneret-Vautrin & Kanny 1995
(55) Wüthrich & Johansson 1995
(56) Wüthrich et al. 1995
(57) Armisen Pedrejon et al. 1996
(58) Cavataio et al. 1996
(59) Guinnepain et al. 1996
(60) Iacono et al. 1996
(61) Levy et al. 1996a
(62) Levy et al. 1996b
(63) Paranos & Nikolic 1996
(64) Tabar et al. 1996
(65) Weisselberg et al. 1996
(66) Jonkhoff-Slok et al. 1997
(67) Iacono et al. 1998a, 1998b
(68) Iacono et al. 1998c
(69) Jarvinen et al. 1998
(70) Kanny et al. 1998
(71) Laoprasert et al. 1998
(72) Sicherer et al. 1998
(73) Vila Sexto et al. 1998
(74) Altuntas et al. 1999
(75) Fiocchi et al. 1999
(76) Goh et al. 1999
(77) Juntti et al. 1999
(78) Rance et al. 1999b
(79) Rizk et al. 1999
(80) Yazicioglu et al. 1999
(81) Businco et al. 2000
(82) Eigenmann & Calza 2000
(83) Nucera et al. 2000b
(84) Patenaude et al. 2000
(85) Rossel et al. 2000
(86) Saarinen & Savilahti 2000
(87) Szabó & Eigenmann 2000
(88) Schade et al. 2000
(89) Bock et al. 2001
(90) Daher et al. 2001
(91) Eggesbø et al. 2001
(92) Järvinen et al. 2001
(93) Kawano et al. 2001
(94) Kokkonen et al. 2001a
(95) Marr et al. 2001
(96) Moneret-Vautrin et al. 2001
(97) Pumberger et al. 2001
(98) Ravelli et al. 2001
(99) Sicherer et al. 2001
(100) Tan et al. 2001
Percentage of Reactions References
Symptoms / Ref. (1)  (2)  (3) (4)  (5) (6)  (7) (8)  (9) (10) (11) (12) (13)
Anaphylaxis 5% 100%     5%       2%   7.8%   1%
Cutaneous       64%   31% 79% 93%   58%      
+ Gastrointestinal                   19%      
+ Respiratory                   13%      
All 3 organ systems                   4%      
Atopic dermatitis 41%   21%         100%   100% 50%   44%
Conjunctivitis                     3.1%   4%
Urticaria / Exanthema                         52%
Urticaria / Angio-oedema                     28%    
Angio-oedema   66%     65%       13%        
Urticaria 10%       100%             73%  
Generalized urticaria   69%     45%       10%        
Contact urticaria   59%     80%                
Eczema         33%       13%        
Flare eczema                       7%  
Circumoral lesions                 26%        
Gastrointestinal       59%   50% 42% 65%    4% 7.8%   20%
Vomiting 34%       13%       41%     14%  
Diarrhoea 47%       3%       48%     *  
Colic                 14%     *  
Colitis                 4%        
Abdominal pain 41%                     *  
Respiratory       33%   19% 91% 48%    2%   14% 15%
Allergic rhinitis 43%   43%   28%       21%     15%  
Asthma 37% 55% 40%                    
Cough / Wheeze   48%     65%       29%        
Other 6%                        
Failure to thrive                 22%        
Gastro-oesophageal reflux                 6%        
Convulsion         2%       2%        
No. of patients 45 29 97 39 75 26 34 54 100 47 68 143 118
(1) Goldman et al. 1963a
(2) Schwartz et al. 1987
(3) Bishop et al. 1990
(4) Host & Halken 1990
(5) Schwartz 1991
(6) Schrander et al. 1993b
(7) Stoger & Wüthrich 1993
(8) Sampson & Ho 1997
(9) Hill et al. 1999
(10) Niggemann et al. 1999b
(11) Rance et al. 1999b
(12) Sporik et al. 2000
(13) Saarinen et al. 2001

Children with CMA
diagnosed by
(1) clinical history, oral challenge
(2) clinical history of anaphylactic reactions, RAST
(3) parents reported
(4, 6) elimination/challenge
(5) clinical history, SPT
(8, 10) DBPCFC
(11) labial food challenge
(12) DBPCFC; * together 21%
(13) open challenge

Adults with CMA
diagnosed by
(7) clinical history, RAST

Symptoms, Onset and Doses for Elicitation of Symptoms
in IgE-mediated and non-IgE-mediated CMA
75 IgE-positive and 43 IgE-negative infants with CMA at open challenge (mean age of 6.7 months):
Symptoms IgE-positive IgE-negative
Anaphylactic reaction 1% 0%
Atopic dermatitis 28% 72%
Urticaria / Exanthema 76% 9%
Vomiting 9% 30%
  Immediate vomiting (<2 h) 9% 9%
  Continuous regurgitation 0% 21%
Diarrhoea 0% 23%
Rhinorrhoea 12% 16%
Cough / Wheeze 1% 14%
Allergic conjunctivitis 5% 2%
Multiple organ symptoms 19% 30%
Onset of Symptoms IgE-positive IgE-negative
< 2 hours 68% 16%
2-24 hours 25% 33%
> 24 hours 7% 51%
Cumulative Dose of Cow's Milk IgE-positive IgE-negative
< 20 mL (appr. 750 mg protein) 59% 14%
20-200 mL (appr. 0.75-7.5 g protein) 32% 37%
> 200 mL (appr. 7.5 g protein) 9% 49%
Saarinen & Savilahti 2000
Onset of Symptoms
Type of Reactions (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
immediate 53%   46% 64%    
delayed reactions 47%   54% 28%    
both       8%    
< 30 min         77%  
< 2 hours         23% 49%
< 6 hours   51%        
within 2-24 hours           28%
within 6-12 hours   13%        
within 12-24 hours   10%        
> 24 hours   26%       23%
No. of patients 47 125 50 47 67* 118
* patients selected because of symptoms suggesting immediate-type CMA
(1) Björkstén et al. 1983
(2) Ventura & Greco 1988
(3) Sutas et al. 1997
(4) Niggemann et al. 1999b
(5) Garcia-Ara et al. 2001
(6) Saarinen et al. 2001
 

Children with CMA
diagnosed by
(1) clinical history
(2) elimination / challenge
(3, 4) DBPCFC
(5, 6) open challenge

Onset of Symptoms
Type of Reactions At diagnosis 1 year 2 years 3 years of follow-up
immediate (<45 min) 8.1% 5.0% 7.8% 0%
intermediate (1-24 h) 77% 67% 51% 31%
delayed (24-72 h) 15% 23% 26% 38%
very delayed (>72 h)* 0% 5.0% 15% 31%
No. of symptomatic patients 86 60 39 26
86 consecutive children with IgE-mediated or non-IgE-mediated CMA (median age at diagnosis 4 months, DBPCFC)
* symptoms of constipation, dermatitis, and wheezing
Carroccio et al. 2000b
Onset of Symptoms
Immediate onset reactions occurred in 43% of positive challenges after a cumulative time of 36 min (3 min to 2.0 h) and late onset reactions in 57% of positive challenges after a cumulative time of 54 h (2 to 192 h) (DBPCFC, 59 children with CMA) 
Sütas et al. 2000
Age at Onset of CMA
Onset in 30% of children with CMA in the first month of life (1) and in 96% at <1 year of age (2)
(1) Savilahti 1981
(2) Bock 1987
Cluster Groups
3 clusters of patients with CMA using a K-means algorithm (data of case history and effects of a standardized milk challenge):
Percentage of patients Onset of Symptoms Symptoms Diagnostics
a) 27-32% after <45 min predominantly urticarial and angioedematous eruptions positive skin tests, elevated total and milk specific serum IgE
b) 51-53% 45 min to 20 hours pallor, vomiting, or diarrhea relatively IgA deficient* (1)
c) 17-20% after >20 hours eczematous or bronchitic or diarrheal symptoms positive skin tests and elevated specific IgE only in patients with eczema
*milk- specific IgA, IgG and IgM levels similar in all groups and controls (2)
  • (1) 100 cow's milk allergic children (mean age of 6 month)
  • (2, 3) 47 cow's milk allergic children (age 4-66 months)
(1) Hill et al. 1986
(2) Firer et al. 1987
(3) Hill et al. 1989
Threshold for Elicitation of Symptoms
Challenge Tests:
  • Amounts of cow's milk inducing symptoms ranged from 5 g to 250 g  (DBPCFC) (1)
  • Amounts of milk (dry weight) inducing symptoms: </= 500 mg in 55% (including 26 and 3 positive challenges with 250 mg and 100 mg, respectively)  (DBPCFC, 196 food allergic children with atopic dermatitis) (4)
  • A cumulative dose of 0.78 mg cow's milk powder (0.01 to 6.1 mg) elicited immediate onset reactions in 43% of positive challenges and a cumulative dose of 31.2 mg cow's milk powder (4 to 100 mg) elicited late onset reactions in 57% of positive challenges (DBPCFC, 59 children with CMA) (5)
  • A dose of 2 to 25 mL of cow's milk infant formula elicited symptoms in 58%, a dose of 50 mL in 13%, of 100 mL in 9.2%, and a dose of >100 mL in 7.9% of 76 infants with CMA (age <1 year, open challenge) (6)
  • A threshold of </= 0.1 mL and 1 mL of  cow's milk observed in 1.7% and 5% of patients, respectively (59 patients with CMA, placebo-controlled food challenges) (7)
Accidental Ingestion:
  • Fatal anaphylaxis after ingestion of 100g of a sausage containing 60 mg CAS (2)
  • The quantity of ingested whey proteins elicited anaphylactic reactions in a 3-year-old boy was estimated to be 120-180 µg (equivalent to 23 to 24 µL of milk) (3)
(1) Norgaard & Bindslev-Jensen 1992
(2) Malmheden Yman et al. 1994
(3) Laoprasert et al. 1998
(4) Sicherer et al. 2000
(5) Sütas et al. 2000
(6) Garcia-Ara et al. 2001
(7) Morisset & Moneret-Vautrin 2001

4 Diagnostic Features of Cow's Milk Allergy
5 Therapy of Cow's Milk Allergy
6 Composition of Cow's Milk
7 Allergens of Cow's Milk
8 Isolation & Preparation

9 Cross-Reactivities
10 Stability of Cow's Milk Allergens
11 Allergen Sources
12 Infant Formulas
13 References


copyright © 2000-2002 by matthias besler -  ONLINE PUBLISHER
home: www.food-allergens.de